Home  ›  Articles

Innovation Execution

How to Evaluate Ideas With Criteria People Trust

Idea evaluation criteria earn trust when they are agreed before the ideas arrive, by the people who will be judged by them. Sort the ideas by type, score them simply, settle a disagreement with a small test, and give every idea one of three answers.

Shannon Phillips

October 20, 2026

Two colleagues at a table reviewing printed documents, one making notes

Key takeaways

Agree the idea evaluation criteria before the ideas arrive, with the people who will be judged by them.

Sort ideas into core, adjacent and breakthrough, and start with core.

Keep scoring simple: three or four criteria, scored alone by at least three people.

Settle a disagreement with a small test that takes two hours or costs 20 dollars at most.

Give every idea one of three answers, with the reason: do it, test it more, or put it on the shelf.

Idea Evaluation Criteria: Agree Them Before the Ideas Arrive

Team Collaboration Icon

Definition

Idea evaluation criteria

The questions an organization asks of every idea to decide what happens to it. They are agreed in advance, applied to every idea in the same way, and published where ideas are submitted.

A wall covered in rows of green, blue and pink sticky notes

A wall of ideas, before any decisions.

If Innovation Is Everything, It Is Nothing

Shannon Phillips, Co-Founder of Unbounded Thinking

If innovation is everything, it’s nothing.

Shannon Phillips, Co-Founder and Innovation Strategist

Sort Ideas First: Core, Adjacent and Breakthrough

Core

Improve What Exists

Changes to current products, services and ways of working, for customers and teams already served.

Adjacent

Extend What Works

Something the organization does well, taken to new customers or put to a new use.

Breakthrough

Create What Is New

A new offer or way of operating, for a need the organization does not serve today.

70%

of innovation resources, on average, went to core offerings at the high-performing firms the authors studied

10%

went to transformational initiatives, the category we call breakthrough

Who Sets the Idea Selection Criteria, and Who Scores

A 45-Minute Meeting That Sets the Criteria

1

State the capacity: 5 minutes

The decision maker says how many ideas the team can work on at one time.

2

Write alone: 10 minutes

Each person writes what must be true of an idea before it goes ahead, one point to a note.

3

Reduce to three or four: 10 minutes

Group the notes and keep the points most people raised. Write each as a question two people would answer the same way.

4

Settle the rules: 10 minutes

Agree who scores, who decides, how a tie is broken and what happens when scorers disagree.

5

Check against past ideas: 10 minutes

Apply the criteria to one past idea that worked and one that did not. If they would have chosen badly, change them now.

Instead of

Has high impact

Is feasible

Fits our strategy

Try this

Removes a problem that a named team meets every week

A first test can start within 30 days with the people we have

Supports one of this year’s stated priorities

In practice. Publish the idea evaluation criteria and the scoring rules where ideas are submitted. Review them once a year, and never during an evaluation.

Keep the Idea Scoring Matrix Simple

Page preview of the Weighted Scoring Template

Free templates

Idea management software

Idea Management Software That Takes Ideas to Results

KWOKKA by UBT™ collects ideas from employees across your organization, helps your team decide which ones to pursue, gives each one an owner and a defined path, and records what it delivered.

When People Disagree, Run a Small Test

Key idea

A small test settles a disagreement faster than a debate.

Three Answers: Do It, Test It More, or Put It on the Shelf

Do it

The Idea Goes Ahead

The criteria are met. The idea has an owner, a first step and a date.

Test it more

The Evidence Is Not In

A criterion could not be answered, or the scorers disagreed. A small test is agreed, with a date.

On the shelf

Not Now, With a Reason

The criteria are not met today. The reason is recorded, with what would have to change.

How to Evaluate Ideas: The Checklist

1

Agree

Criteria and scoring rules, before the ideas arrive

2

Sort

Core, adjacent and breakthrough

3

Score

Alone first, then discussed

4

Answer

Do it, test it more, or the shelf

Idea evaluation checklist

Three or four criteria, agreed by the people judged by them

Criteria and scoring rules published before ideas are collected

Ideas sorted into core, adjacent and breakthrough

At least three scorers for each idea, scoring alone first

A small test for every split among the scorers

One of three answers for every idea, with the reason

Limited-time Q4 offer

Innovation Process Certification at 50% Off

Your team can build this on a real problem in our two-day Innovation Process Certification, for up to 10 people. Alberta organizations that book by 30 November pay half our medium business price.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are idea evaluation criteria?

How do you evaluate ideas?

Who should set the idea selection criteria?

What is an idea scoring matrix?

How do you prioritize ideas when there are too many?

What should happen when evaluators disagree about an idea?

About the author

Shannon Phillips, Co-Founder of Unbounded Thinking

Shannon Phillips

Co-Founder and Innovation Strategist

Designs structured innovation systems for enterprise organizations and helps leadership teams set priorities that reflect how the organization operates.

Start With a Free Individual Snapshot

The free Innovation Readiness Snapshot gives one person’s view of the same four areas in about five minutes, with a private summary of your results at the end.