In this article
Innovation Workshops
In each workshop, participants work through their own ideas using a structured innovation process.
Find the Right WorkshopKey takeaways
An idea reaches your manager as extra work, so start from a problem your manager already owns.
Ask for permission to run a small test. It is easier to grant than approval of the whole idea.
Size the first test at two hours or 20 dollars. If it needs more, make it smaller.
Put the proposal on one page with six lines, from the problem to the date you report back.
Ask for one of three answers: do it, test it more, or shelve it with the reason.
How to Present an Idea to Your Boss: Ask for a Test Before Approval
Definition
Idea proposal
A short written request to try an idea at work. It states the problem, the people affected, the idea in one sentence, a small first test and the date the result will be reported.
The short answer to how to present an idea to your boss is to make the request smaller. Start from a problem your manager already owns, put the proposal on one page, and ask for permission to run a small test. Permission to test is a smaller decision than approval of the whole idea, and the result gives your manager evidence for the decision that follows.
Most advice concerns delivery: research the audience, rehearse the pitch and choose a quiet day. Delivery leaves the request unchanged, and the size of the request is usually the obstacle.
We describe people as idea machines. Organizations are rarely short of ideas. They are short of a route from an idea to a change, and a proposal is the first step on that route.
Why an Idea Reaches Your Manager as Extra Work
Leaders often say “bring me your ideas”. The honest reply from many people would be “then take something off my plate”. Your manager is in the same position: a new idea arrives as more work, in a week that is already full.
In a December 2022 Gartner survey of more than 6,000 employees and managers, reported by Workplace Insight, 49% of managers said the complexity of their responsibilities had increased. Research published in Organization Science in 2019 found that managers often avoid asking for employees’ ideas when they have little authority to make changes and are under pressure to deliver short-term results.
A hesitant manager may be interested in the idea and unable to take it on. A proposal is easier to accept when it shows whose problem it solves, how little it needs from your manager and who will do the work.
Start From a Problem Your Manager Already Owns
A manager owns a problem when it appears in their targets, their reports or the complaints they receive. An idea attached to such a problem needs no separate argument for why it matters. Any other idea competes with everything already on your manager’s list.
State the problem before the idea, with a number where you have one:
Instead of
We should use a shared tracker for client requests
We need new scheduling software
Try this
Three client requests were missed last month. I would like to test a shared tracker on two accounts
Shift swaps take the supervisors four hours a week. I would like to try a sign-up sheet with one team
In practice. Use your manager’s own words for the problem: the phrase from the last team meeting, or the measure on the monthly report.
Ask for a Small Test: The 2 Hour, $20 Test
Approving a whole idea commits budget and people before anyone knows whether the idea works. Allowing a small test is a smaller decision. It usually sits within your manager’s own authority, and it can be made in one conversation.
Key idea
Permission to test is easier to grant than approval of the whole idea.
Unbounded Thinking’s 2 Hour, $20 Test is the rule we use to keep a first test small:
From our workshops
The 2 Hour, $20 Test
If a first test of an idea cannot be done within two hours or for 20 dollars, make the test smaller. Take an employee whose accounting process takes ten hours. The request to the manager is short: “I have an idea to turn my ten-hour accounting process into a two-hour process. Can we try it?”
A request of that size asks little of a manager. If the idea saves 20 percent of a team’s time next month, it needed no budget and no innovation team. It needed permission to try.
Most ideas can be reduced to a test of this size:
One run. Try the new method once, beside the old one.
One small group. One team, one customer or one shift.
A manual version. A spreadsheet or a paper form in place of new software.
We teach this test in our innovation workshops, where participants work through their own ideas using a structured innovation process.
Workshops and Certification
Innovation Workshops
In each workshop, participants work through their own ideas using a structured innovation process.
How to Write a Proposal for an Idea at Work: One Page, Six Lines
Guidance on how to write a proposal for an idea at work often produces a long document. A first request needs one page with six lines:
1
The problem
What goes wrong today, with a number if you have one: hours, errors, complaints or delays.
2
Who it affects
The people who lose time because of it, and the target of your manager’s that it touches.
3
The idea in one sentence
What you would do differently. An idea that needs a paragraph is not yet clear enough to test.
4
The small test
What you will try, with whom and for how long, and what it needs from your manager.
5
What you will measure
The one result that will show whether the idea works.
6
When you will report back
A date, and the decision you will ask for on that date.
Leave out the full business case and the rollout plan. They belong to the decision that follows a successful test.
A worked example
The Six Lines, Filled In
Problem: closing the month takes me ten hours. Who it affects: the finance team, and the date your monthly report goes out. Idea: check only the entries that a prepared spreadsheet flags. Test: both methods on last month’s figures, for two hours on Thursday. Measure: the time taken, and whether the totals agree. Report back: Friday, with a request to adopt it, test it again or drop it.
How to Pitch an Idea to Your Boss in One Conversation
With the page written, the conversation is short. Advice on how to pitch an idea to your boss gives much attention to timing and rehearsal, which matter less when the request is small. Three points are enough:
Use a meeting that already exists. A special meeting signals a large request.
Lead with the problem and the request. One sentence for each, then hand over the page.
Ask for a decision on the test only. The larger decision can wait for the result.
Those who ask how to pitch an idea to management above their own manager face the same constraint on a larger scale. Involve your manager first, bring the result of a first test, and keep to the one page.
Three Answers to Expect: Do It, Test It More or Shelve It
Guides on how to present an idea to your boss usually end at the pitch. The reply matters as much. Every idea deserves one of three answers, and a proposal built around a test makes each of them easy to give.
Do it
The Result Is Clear
The test worked and the change is small enough to adopt. Agree who makes it standard, and by when.
Test it more
The Result Is Promising
The test left a question open. Agree a slightly larger test and a new date.
Shelve it
The Evidence or the Timing Is Against It
The idea goes on the shelf with the reason recorded, so that it can be reopened later.
When you report back, ask for one of the three by name. A request for feedback invites a discussion without a decision.
If the idea is shelved, ask for the reason and write it on the page. The reason shows what would have to change, and it improves your next proposal.
If You Are the Manager Who Receives the Proposal
The proposal is half of the exchange. If you manage people and want them to keep bringing ideas, three habits complete it:
Decide on the test quickly. A two-hour test rarely needs more than a day to approve.
Give one of the three answers. Do it, test it more, or shelve it with the reason.
Make room in advance. Say how much time your team may spend on a first test without asking.
Our article on how to respond to employee ideas covers the reply in detail: what to say, how quickly, and how to decline an idea without discouraging the next one.
Where every proposal depends on one employee’s persistence and one manager’s goodwill, good ideas are lost. Organizations rarely have an idea problem. They have an execution problem, and often a system problem: no shared route from an idea to a decision. Idea management software can provide that route, and our article on why good ideas are not implemented covers what follows approval.
How to Propose an Idea to Management: Four Steps
Put together, these practices answer the question of how to propose an idea to management in four steps:
1
Problem
One your manager already owns
2
Test
Two hours or 20 dollars
3
Page
Six lines, in plain words
4
Answer
Do it, test it more or shelve it
An idea is content. Its value lies in the change it leads to, and a small test is the shortest route from one to the other. Knowing how to present an idea to your boss helps one idea at a time. For a first look at how your organization handles ideas in general, one person can take the free Innovation Readiness Snapshot.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you present an idea to your boss?
Start from a problem your manager already owns, put the proposal on one page, and ask for permission to run a small test. Permission to test is a smaller decision than approval of the whole idea.
What should a template for presenting an idea to your boss include?
Six lines on one page: the problem, who it affects, the idea in one sentence, the small test, what you will measure, and when you will report back. A first request does not need slides.
What is an example of how to propose an idea to your boss?
“Closing the month takes me ten hours, and I have an idea that could bring it down to two. Can I try it once on last month’s figures and show you the result on Friday?” The request names the problem, the idea and a small test.
What is the 2 Hour, $20 Test?
The 2 Hour, $20 Test is Unbounded Thinking’s rule for the first test of an idea: if the test cannot be done within two hours or for 20 dollars, make the test smaller.
How do you pitch an idea to senior management?
Involve your own manager first, bring the result of a first test, and keep the proposal to one page. Senior leaders have less time, so a small request with evidence is easier to decide.
What should you do if your boss says no to your idea?
Ask for the reason and record it with the proposal. An idea shelved with a reason can be reopened when conditions change, and the reason shows what your next proposal has to address.
About the author
Shannon Phillips
Co-Founder and Innovation Strategist
Designs structured innovation systems for enterprise organizations and helps leadership teams set priorities that reflect how the organization operates.
Related Articles
Psychological Safety
How to Respond to Employee Ideas So People Keep Sharing
Innovation Execution
Why Good Ideas Are Not Implemented, and What to Change
Innovation Execution