Home  ›  Articles

Employee Ideas

How to Run a Brainstorming Session That Ends in Decisions

Most advice on how to run a brainstorming session covers ways to produce ideas. A session ends in decisions when the question, the decision maker and the criteria are settled before it starts, and time is kept for choosing.

Shannon Phillips

October 9, 2026

Two colleagues discussing sticky notes on a window, one pointing at a note

Key takeaways

Before sending the invitation, name the decision the session must produce and the person who makes it.

Write one clear question, and send it with three or four criteria two working days ahead.

Ask participants to write ideas alone before the group discusses them.

Keep the second half of the session for narrowing the list and choosing.

Record an owner, a next step and a date for each chosen idea before people leave.

Why Most Brainstorming Sessions End Without a Decision

Team Collaboration Icon

Definition

Brainstorming session

A meeting in which a group produces many possible answers to one question and holds back judgement until the ideas have been shared.

1

Prepare

The decision, the question and the criteria

2

Generate

Ideas written alone, then shared

3

Converge

The list narrowed against the criteria

4

Commit

Choices, owners and next steps

Before the Session: Name the Decision and Who Makes It

In the session

The Group Decides

Participants choose together, by vote or by scoring, and the result stands.

In the session

The Leader Decides

The group recommends, and the decision maker chooses before the session closes.

By a set date

The Leader Decides Later

The group recommends a short list. The decision maker answers by a date announced in the session.

Write One Clear Question

Instead of

Ideas for improving onboarding

How to increase sales

Thoughts on the new intranet

Try this

How might we halve the time a new employee needs before taking a customer call alone?

How might we win a second order from customers who bought once this year?

How might we make the five most used forms easier to find?

In practice. Send the decision, the question and the criteria to participants at least two working days before the session.

Invite the People the Decision Needs

Agree the Criteria Before Anyone Has an Idea

Key idea

Criteria set before the session produce a decision that can be explained to the people whose ideas were not chosen.

How to Structure a Brainstorming Session: Generate, Then Converge

1

Open: 10 minutes

Restate the decision, the question and the criteria. Confirm who decides and how.

2

Write alone: 10 minutes

Each person writes ideas in silence, one idea to a note.

3

Share and build: 25 minutes

Each idea is read out without debate. The group combines duplicates and adds the ideas that others prompt.

4

Converge: 30 minutes

Group the ideas, score the groups against the criteria and discuss only the few that score highest.

5

Commit: 15 minutes

Confirm the choices, name the owners and agree the next steps.

In practice. When the generating phase runs long, shorten the sharing and keep the converging.

Brainstorming Session Rules and the Facilitator’s Role

Team Collaboration Icon

Workshops and Certification

Innovation Workshops

In each workshop, participants work through their own ideas using a structured innovation process.

Before People Leave: Choices, Owners and Next Steps

How to Run a Brainstorming Session: The Checklist

Brainstorming session checklist

The decision the session must produce is written down

The decision maker is named, and participants know how the choice will be made

One clear question and three or four criteria went out with the invitation

The agenda has participants write ideas alone before the group discusses them

The second half of the session is kept for converging and committing

Each chosen idea leaves with an owner, a next step and a date

Frequently Asked Questions

How to run a brainstorming session that ends in decisions?

How do you structure a brainstorming session?

What are the rules of a brainstorming session?

How do you facilitate a brainstorming session?

Who should attend a brainstorming session?

How long should a brainstorming session be?

About the author

Shannon Phillips, Co-Founder of Unbounded Thinking

Shannon Phillips

Co-Founder and Innovation Strategist

Designs structured innovation systems for enterprise organizations and helps leadership teams set priorities that reflect how the organization operates.

Start With a Free Individual Snapshot

The free Innovation Readiness Snapshot gives one person’s view of the same four areas in about five minutes, with a private summary of your results at the end.